The average train between Bay Shore and Montclair takes 2h 35m and the fastest train takes 2h 10m. There is a train service every few hours from Bay Shore to Montclair. The journey time may be longer on weekends and holidays; use the search form on this page to search for a specific travel date.
Trains run every 2 hours between Bay Shore and Montclair. The earliest departure is at 5:04 AM in the morning, and the last departure from Bay Shore is at 10:56 PM which arrives into Montclair at 1:13 AM. All services require a transfer at Babylon and take an average of 2h 35m. The schedules shown below are for the next available departures.


2h 27m • 2 changes

2h 10m • 2 changes

2h 35m • 2 changes

3h 1m • 2 changes

2h 27m • 2 changes

2h 10m • 2 changes

2h 35m • 2 changes

3h 1m • 2 changes

2h 27m • 2 changes

2h 10m • 2 changes

2h 35m • 2 changes

3h 1m • 2 changes

2h 27m • 2 changes

2h 10m • 2 changes

2h 35m • 2 changes

3h 1m • 2 changesWant to know about travelling from Bay Shore to Montclair? We have put together a list of the most frequently asked questions from our users such as: What is the cheapest mode of transport? What is the quickest option? How much do tickets usually cost? and many more.
No, there is no direct train from Bay Shore to Montclair. However, there are services departing from Babylon station and arriving at Watchung Avenue station via New York Penn Station. The journey, including transfers, takes approximately 2h 35m.
Bay Shore to Montclair train services, operated by Long Island Rail Road, depart from Babylon station.
Bay Shore to Montclair train services, operated by NJ Transit, arrive at Watchung Avenue station.
The distance between Bay Shore and Montclair is 81.9 km. The road distance is 95 km.
You can take a train from Bay Shore to Watchung Avenue via Babylon and New York Penn Station in around 3h 2m.