Rome2Rio

Middletown to Bay Shore trains

Find Transport to Bay Shore

View schedule

Trip Overview

The average train between Middletown and Bay Shore takes 3h 4m and the fastest train takes 2h 40m. The train service runs several times per day from Middletown to Bay Shore. The journey time may be longer on weekends and holidays; use the search form on this page to search for a specific travel date.

3h 4m
Duration
83 mi
Distance
$33
Average price
Every 2 hours
Frequency

Train via Queens

best
  1. Take the train from Middletown Nj to New York Penn Stationtrain train Njcl / ...
  2. Take the train from Jamaica to Bay Shoretrain train Montauk Branch
3h 33m
$14–45

Middletown to Bay Shore train times

Trains run every 2 hours between Middletown and Bay Shore. The earliest departure is at 4:41 AM at night, and the last departure from Middletown is at 10:47 PM which arrives into Bay Shore at 1:48 AM. All services require a transfer at New York Penn Station and take an average of 3h 4m. The schedules shown below are for the next available departures.

Departing Saturday, October 10, 2026

  •  → 

    NJ TransitLong Island Rail RoadLong Island Rail Road2h 55m • 2 changes

  •  → 

    NJ TransitLong Island Rail RoadLong Island Rail Road3h 52m • 2 changes

  •  → 

    NJ TransitLong Island Rail RoadLong Island Rail Road3h 31m • 2 changes

  •  → 

    NJ TransitLong Island Rail RoadLong Island Rail Road3h 32m • 2 changes
  • Show more

Departing Sunday, October 11, 2026

  •  → 

    NJ TransitLong Island Rail RoadLong Island Rail Road3h 15m • 2 changes

  •  → 

    NJ TransitLong Island Rail RoadLong Island Rail Road3h 4m • 2 changes

  •  → 

    NJ TransitLong Island Rail RoadLong Island Rail Road3h 17m • 2 changes

  •  → 

    NJ TransitLong Island Rail RoadLong Island Rail Road2h 48m • 2 changes
  • Show more

Departing Monday, October 12, 2026

  •  → 

    NJ TransitLong Island Rail RoadLong Island Rail Road2h 48m • 2 changes

  •  → 

    NJ TransitLong Island Rail RoadLong Island Rail Road2h 49m • 2 changes

  •  → 

    NJ TransitLong Island Rail RoadLong Island Rail Road3h 14m • 2 changes

  •  → 

    NJ TransitLong Island Rail RoadLong Island Rail Road3h 9m • 2 changes
  • Show more

Departing Tuesday, October 13, 2026

  •  → 

    NJ TransitLong Island Rail RoadLong Island Rail Road2h 46m • 2 changes

  •  → 

    NJ TransitLong Island Rail RoadLong Island Rail Road3h 21m • 2 changes

  •  → 

    NJ TransitLong Island Rail RoadLong Island Rail Road3h 14m • 2 changes

  •  → 

    NJ TransitLong Island Rail RoadLong Island Rail Road3h 9m • 2 changes
  • Show more

Departing Wednesday, October 14, 2026

  •  → 

    NJ TransitLong Island Rail RoadLong Island Rail Road2h 46m • 2 changes

  •  → 

    NJ TransitLong Island Rail RoadLong Island Rail Road3h 21m • 2 changes

  •  → 

    NJ TransitLong Island Rail RoadLong Island Rail Road3h 14m • 2 changes

  •  → 

    NJ TransitLong Island Rail RoadLong Island Rail Road3h 9m • 2 changes
  • Show more

Departing Thursday, October 15, 2026

  •  → 

    NJ TransitLong Island Rail RoadLong Island Rail Road2h 46m • 2 changes

Frequently asked questions

Want to know about travelling from Middletown to Bay Shore? We have put together a list of the most frequently asked questions from our users such as: What is the cheapest mode of transport? What is the quickest option? How much do tickets usually cost? and many more.

Map of how to get from Middletown to Bay Shore.ExpandLaunch map view
  • Distance: 83.3 mi
  • Duration: 3h 4m

What companies run services between Middletown, Monmouth County, NJ, USA and Bay Shore, NY, USA?

You can take a train from Middletown Nj to Bay Shore via New York Penn Station and Jamaica in around 3h 33m.

Operators