Montauk to Sheepshead Bay (Water) Trains

Montauk to Sheepshead Bay (Water) trains

Travel from

Search accommodation with Expedia

Trip Overview

The average train between Montauk and Sheepshead Bay (Water) takes 4h 7m and the fastest train takes 3h 47m. The train runs, on average, 6 times per week from Montauk to Sheepshead Bay (Water). The journey time may be longer on weekends and holidays; use the search form on this page to search for a specific travel date.

4h 7m
Duration: 122 mi
Distance: $53
Average price: 6 times a week
Frequency

Train

best

Take the train from Montauk to Jamaicatrain Montauk Branch

3h 58m

$30–67

Montauk to Sheepshead Bay (Water) train times

Trains run 6 times a week between Montauk and Sheepshead Bay (Water). The earliest departure is at 7:00 AM in the morning, and the last departure from Montauk is at 7:56 PM which arrives into Sheepshead Bay (Water) at 11:45 PM. All services require a transfer at Jamaica and take an average of 4h 7m. The schedules shown below are for the next available departures.

Departing Sunday, October 25, 2026

7:00 AM → 11:06 AM
4h 6m • 2 changes
11:36 AM → 3:31 PM
3h 55m • 2 changes
3:20 PM → 7:07 PM
3h 47m • 2 changes
5:18 PM → 9:12 PM
3h 54m • 2 changes
Show more

Frequently asked questions

Want to know about travelling from Montauk to Sheepshead Bay (Water)? We have put together a list of the most frequently asked questions from our users such as: What is the cheapest mode of transport? What is the quickest option? How much do tickets usually cost? and many more.