There are 3 ways to get from Bay Shore to Middletown by train, bus, or car
Select an option below to see step-by-step directions and to compare ticket prices and travel times in Rome2Rio's travel planner.
Train
best- Take the train from Babylon to New York Penn Stationtrain Babylon Branch / ...
- Take the train from New York Penn Station to Middletown Njtrain Njcl / ...
3h 19m$14–46Line 2 bus, train, bus
- Take the bus from Third Ave/Mechanicsville Rd to Amityville LIRRbus 2
- Take the train from Amityville to New York Penn Stationtrain
- Take the bus from New York, NY - Port Authority to Rt-35 At New Monmouth Rdbus
4h 23m$42–68Drive 77.1 mi
- Drive from Bay Shore to Middletowncar 77.1 mi
1h 53m$15–21
Bay Shore to Middletown by train
Comparing Your Travel Options
The cheapest way to get from Bay Shore to Middletown is to drive which costs $14 - $21 and takes 1h 53m.
The fastest way to get from Bay Shore to Middletown is to drive which takes 1h 53m and costs $14 - $21.
No, there is no direct train from Bay Shore to Middletown. However, there are services departing from Bay Shore and arriving at Middletown Nj via Babylon and New York Penn Station. The journey, including transfers, takes approximately 3h 19m.
The distance between Bay Shore and Middletown is 84 miles. The road distance is 77.6 miles.
The best way to get from Bay Shore to Middletown without a car is to train which takes 3h 19m and costs $13 - $50.
It takes approximately 3h 19m to get from Bay Shore to Middletown, including transfers.
Bay Shore to Middletown train services, operated by Long Island Rail Road, depart from Babylon station.
Bay Shore to Middletown train services, operated by Long Island Rail Road, arrive at New York Penn Station.
Yes, the driving distance between Bay Shore to Middletown is 78 miles. It takes approximately 1h 53m to drive from Bay Shore to Middletown.
There are 149+ hotels available in Middletown.
What companies run services between Bay Shore, NY, USA and Middletown, Monmouth County, NJ, USA?
You can take a train from Bay Shore to Middletown Nj via Babylon and New York Penn Station in around 3h 19m.
- Phone
- +1-718-217-5477
- Website
- Long Island Rail Road
Train from Babylon to New York Penn Station
- Ave. Duration
- 1h 12m
- Frequency
- Every 30 minutes
- Estimated price
- $8–20
- Website
- Long Island Rail Road
- Schedules at
- Long Island Rail Road Schedules
- Off-Peak
- $8–11
- Peak
- $16–20
Train from Amityville to New York Penn Station
- Ave. Duration
- 1h 1m
- Frequency
- Hourly
- Estimated price
- $10–21
- Website
- Long Island Rail Road
- Schedules at
- Long Island Rail Road Schedules
- Off-Peak
- $10–14
- Peak
- $15–21
- Phone
- +1 973-275-5555
- Website
- New Jersey Transit
Train from New York Penn Station to Middletown Nj
- Ave. Duration
- 1h 19m
- Frequency
- Hourly
- Estimated price
- $3–21
- Website
- New Jersey Transit
- Website
- NJ Transit: World Cup 2026
- Adult
- $3–21
- Phone
- 631 852 5200
- [email protected]
- Website
- Suffolk County Transit
Bus from Third Ave/Mechanicsville Rd to Amityville LIRR
- Ave. Duration
- 43 min
- Frequency
- Hourly
- Estimated price
- $3
- Schedules at
- Suffolk County Transit
- Adults
- $3
- Phone
- +1 201-420-7000
- Website
- Academy Bus
Bus from New York, NY - Port Authority to Rt-35 At New Monmouth Rd
- Ave. Duration
- 1h 8m
- Frequency
- Twice daily
- Estimated price
- $30–45
- Website
- Academy Bus
- Schedules at
- Academy Bus
- Adult cash ticket
- $30–45
Want to know more about travelling around the world?
Rome2Rio's Travel Guide series provide vital information for the global traveller. Read our range of informative guides on popular transport routes and companies - including Need to know: Greyhound, Need to know: Eurostar, and Flying into Beijing? - to help you get the most out of your next trip.