Rome2Rio

How to get fromBuffalo to Shelter Islandby plane, train, unknown, or bus

Find Transport to Shelter Island

See all options

There are 10 ways to get from Buffalo to Shelter Island by plane, train, unknown, or bus

Select an option below to see step-by-step directions and to compare ticket prices and travel times in Rome2Rio's travel planner.

  1. Fly Buffalo Niagara International Airport to John F. Kennedy International Airport, train, travel

    best
    1. Fly from Buffalo Niagara International Airport (BUF) to John F. Kennedy International Airport (JFK)plane plane BUF - JFK
    2. Take the train from Jamaica to Ronkonkomatrain train
    3. Take the train from Ronkonkoma to Greenporttrain train
    4. Walk from Greenport to Shelter Islandunknown unknown
    6h 27m

  2. Bus, travel via Sag Harbor Westbound

    1. Take the bus from Buffalo to New Yorkbus bus
    2. Take the bus from 79th St & Broadway to Sag Harbor Westboundbus bus
    3. Walk from Sag Harbor Westbound to Shelter Islandunknown unknown
    11h 41m

  3. Train, travel via New York

    1. Take the train from Buffalo to Ny Moynihan Train Hall At Penn Stationtrain train
    2. Take the train from New York Penn Station to Ronkonkomatrain train
    3. Take the train from Ronkonkoma to Greenporttrain train
    4. Walk from Greenport to Shelter Islandunknown unknown
    12h 20m

  4. Fly Buffalo Niagara International Airport to Laguardia Airport, train, travel

    1. Fly from Buffalo Niagara International Airport (BUF) to Laguardia Airport (LGA)plane plane BUF - LGA
    2. Take the train from Woodside to Ronkonkomatrain train
    3. Take the train from Ronkonkoma to Greenporttrain train
    4. Walk from Greenport to Shelter Islandunknown unknown
    6h 55m

  5. Fly Buffalo Niagara International Airport to Boston Logan Airport, train, travel

    1. Fly from Buffalo Niagara International Airport (BUF) to Boston Logan Airport (BOS)plane plane BUF - BOS
    2. Take the train from Boston to Old Saybrook Amtrak Stationtrain train
    3. Walk from Old Saybrook Amtrak Station to Shelter Islandunknown unknown
    6h 19m

  6. Fly Buffalo Niagara International Airport to Newark Liberty International Airport, train, travel

    1. Fly from Buffalo Niagara International Airport (BUF) to Newark Liberty International Airport (EWR)plane plane BUF - EWR
    2. Take the train from New York Penn Station to Ronkonkomatrain train
    3. Take the train from Ronkonkoma to Greenporttrain train
    4. Walk from Greenport to Shelter Islandunknown unknown
    7h 27m

  7. Bus to Rochester, fly to Laguardia Airport, train, travel

    1. Take the bus from Buffalo to Rochester Bus Stopbus bus
    2. Fly from Rochester (ROC) to Laguardia Airport (LGA)plane plane ROC - LGA
    3. Take the train from Woodside to Ronkonkomatrain train
    4. Take the train from Ronkonkoma to Greenporttrain train
    5. Walk from Greenport to Shelter Islandunknown unknown
    8h 27m

  8. Fly Buffalo Niagara International Airport to Philadelphia International Airport, train, travel

    1. Fly from Buffalo Niagara International Airport (BUF) to Philadelphia International Airport (PHL)plane plane BUF - PHL
    2. Take the train from 30th Street Station to Ny Moynihan Train Hall At Penn Stationtrain train
    3. Take the train from New York Penn Station to Ronkonkomatrain train
    4. Take the train from Ronkonkoma to Greenporttrain train
    5. Walk from Greenport to Shelter Islandunknown unknown
    9h

  9. Train, travel

    1. Take the train from Buffalo to New York Penn Stationtrain train
    2. Take the train from New York Penn Station to Ronkonkomatrain train
    3. Take the train from Ronkonkoma to Greenporttrain train
    4. Walk from Greenport to Shelter Islandunknown unknown
    13h 4m

  10. Bus, travel

    1. Take the bus from Buffalo to New York Midtownbus bus
    2. Take the bus from Boerum Hill-Atlantic & 4 Av to Greenportbus bus
    3. Walk from Greenport to Shelter Islandunknown unknown
    13h 23m

Buffalo Niagara International Airport (BUF) to John F. Kennedy International Airport (JFK) flights

Calendar62Weekly Planes
Duration1h 45mAverage Duration
Ticket$52Cheapest Price
See schedules

Questions & Answers

Map of how to get from Buffalo to Shelter Island.ExpandLaunch map view
  • Distance: 403.1 mi
  • Duration: 6h 27m

What companies run services between Buffalo, NY, USA and Shelter Island, NY, USA?

There is no direct connection from Buffalo to Shelter Island. However, you can take the bus to Buffalo Niagara International Airport, walk to Buffalo Niagara International Airport (BUF) airport, fly to John F. Kennedy International Airport (JFK), walk to Terminal 4, take the vehicle to Jamaica Station, walk to Jamaica, take the train to Ronkonkoma, take the train to Greenport, then travel to Shelter Island. Alternatively, you can take a bus from Buffalo to Shelter Island via W 41 St/8 Av, Broadway/W 77 St, 79th St & Broadway, and Sag Harbor Westbound in around 11h 41m.

Airlines
Train operators
Bus operators

Want to know more about travelling around United States

Rome2Rio's Travel Guide series provide vital information for the global traveller. Filled with useful and timely travel information, the guides answer all the hard questions - such as 'How do I buy a ticket?', 'Should I book online before I travel? ', 'How much should I expect to pay?', 'Do the trains and buses have Wifi?' - to help you get the most out of your next trip.

Related travel guides